Trump vs. Chicago: Potential EPA Office Closure

Chicago from the air over Lake Michigan

OZinOH via Flickr

President Trump clearly doesn’t like Chicago. He takes a swipe at the city every chance he gets.

But the latest salvo in his war on Chicago is likely to impact a lot more than just the Second City.

Chicago Sun-Times columnist Michael Sneed had an item summarizing a rumor we have been hearing a lot of lately: that beyond the massive cuts already in store for critical protections of clean air, water and the EPA, there may be a plan afoot to close the Agency’s Region 5 office in Chicago and merge it with operations in Kansas City.

The Administration denies that there is a plan in place…sort of…calling press reports unsubstantiated rumor, but admitting that they may merge some offices.

But even in this world of #FakeNews, sometimes rumors aren’t just coming out of nowhere. In this case, leaked EPA budget documents include some salient passages (bold formatting is mine) that imply this move is already indeed under consideration:

Funding levels incorporate rent cost avoidance from several regional and headquarters offices Potomac Yards North, Region 1, Region 5, and Region 9), the decommissioning of part of the Las Vegas laboratory, and the release of the headquarters warehouse in Washington D.C.

Workforce:

The budget includes significant reductions in FTE. The hiring freeze will remain in place while the agency develops a comprehensive workforce reshaping plan. The agency will chart a workforce path that seeks to align capacity with Administration priorities, takes advantage of opportunities for more efficient practices and organizational structures, minimizes separation costs, and enables adjustment to final appropriation levels without major disruptions to the agency's work. Further guidance from OMB and OPM is expected to guide development for workforce reshaping plans.

Physical Footprint:

OARM and OCFO will work with impacted program and regional offices as work proceeds on the strategic review with OMB and GSA to analyze the needs of the agency regarding its physical footprint, including that of office, warehouse, and laboratory space. The agency is seeking opportunities to further reduce our facility footprint and/or implement planned and pending moves/consolidation in an expedited and most cost effective manner.

The Region 5 office in Chicago is the largest in EPA. And much of its staff has specialized experience. A lot of that is already threatened by the ludicrous and dangerous budget cuts that have already been outlined, including the zeroing out of the Great Lakes Restoration Initiative, as well as drinking water, superfund and Environmental Justice programs.

The programs lost are bad enough. But in many cases the staff are irreplaceable—taking with them deep understanding of highly technical and complicated environmental issues. When that specialized staff is gone, that knowledge is gone too. The KC EPA staff is great, but focused on very different issues in predominantly agricultural states. With their own staff cuts to contend with, how focused will they be on the water and industrial contamination issues that Region 5 has been dealing with out of the Chicago office? The special interests holding sway over the White House are clearly banking on the answer of “not very.”

How will the fate of the Great Lakes―95% of the available fresh water in our nation―be properly protected from distant Kansas City? The elimination of programs associated with the largest freshwater ecosystem in the western hemisphere is dangerous and short-sighted. Dumping the folks who understand it and have been tasked with protecting that ecosystem, as well as the communities reliant upon it. Well, that doesn’t just hurt Chicago. It’s a blow that will likely be felt in Ohio, Michigan, Wisconsin, Illinois, Minnesota and Indiana for decades to come. (New York and Pennsylvania too!)

UPDATE: Administrator Pruitt is in Chicagoland today. He is visiting East Chicago to hear about that city’s ongoing lead issues (see my colleague Meleah Geertsma’s blog on Pruitt’s inaction on the petition to use his emergency powers under the Safe Drinking Water Act to offer immediate help on the emerging water crisis). Afterwards, he will pop into Chicago. But, according to press reports, despite a request from staff for him to come into the Region 5 officeAdministrator Pruitt will be going to the Cubs game instead. The Cubs are great and all…but this is not an either/or choice. He should be able to meet with critically important staff, who report to him and have an essential role in advancing health and safety; AND go to Cubs game by properly scheduling his time.

About the Authors

Henry Henderson

Director, Midwest program

Join Us