A Single Discarded Fishing Net Can Keep Killing for Centuries

A new report estimates that around 700,000 tons of fishing gear are abandoned in the oceans each year. Now the good news: We can curb this.

May 17, 2018

© Alessio Viora/Marine Photobank

Divers off the coast of the Cayman Islands last month came face to face with a ghoulish sight: a gigantic mass of abandoned fishing gear and its catch. The monstrous net, as wide and deep as the Hollywood sign is tall, drifted just below the water’s surface with tendrils that teemed with hundreds of dead and dying fish and sharks.

The divers attempted to cut some of the trapped souls from the tangled mess of netting and buoys, but most of them were already lost. Many more had been dead for so long, the divers said, that it was impossible to tell what species they were. The men tried to haul the massive net back to shore but said it was much too heavy for their boat to tow. (The Department of the Environment of the Caymans later recovered the net. Volunteers cut up the tangled mess and shipped it to Parley for the Oceans, who plans to turn it into new products.)

This knot of ruin is completely unremarkable in the context of the global “ghost gear” crisis. A new report from the international nonprofit World Animal Protection (WAP) estimates that at least 700,000 tons of new ghost gear enter the sea each year. Once it’s there, the flotsam can harm all kinds of sea life, including turtles, penguins, sea lions, dolphins, whales, and diving shorebirds. The report found that 45 percent of all the marine mammals listed on the International Union for Conservation of Nature’s Red List of Threatened Species have been killed or harmed by abandoned fishing gear.

“It’s not shocking to me,” says Charles Grisafi, the Florida and Caribbean regional coordinator for the NOAA Marine Debris Program. “These nets are huge. You can see gill nets out there over two miles long.”

Two. Miles. Long.

Ocean plastic has garnered lots of attention in recent years (as it should), but fishing gear makes up a huge chunk of that problematic plastic. Unlike plastic bottles, drinking straws, and grocery bags, this gear was designed for one purpose: catching and killing sea life. And it continues to do so long after the anglers who deployed it return to shore.

Ghost gear masses like the Caribbean discovery are essentially giant fish traps that perpetually re-bait themselves. The trapped animals attract predators and scavengers who then become ensnared themselves. After death, their rotting carcasses draw in still more victims and the cycle goes on and on, basically forever.

This is not hyperbole. The plastics that make up most of the nets in the oceans today take around 600 years to break apart. One old gill net found wedged between rocks off the coast of the San Juan Islands reportedly sat atop a pile of marine bird and mammal bones that was three feet deep.

Stop the assault on whales, dolphins, and other marine mammals

For larger animals like whales, entanglements don’t always bring a quick death. They instead confer a life sentence of towing around a heavy aquatic ball and chain, the health effects of which scientists are only beginning to understand. (Spoiler alert: It ain’t good.) And as with other ocean pollution, some animals eat ghost gear, as evidenced by necropsies of 22 sperm whales stranded in the North Sea. Of all the nonfood items in their guts, 78 percent was fishing gear, including, in one case, a plastic fishing net that was more than 42 feet long.

Forty-two. Feet. Long.

World Animal Protection's Elizabeth Hogan on a beach survey and cleanup in Hawaii

World Animal Protection/Rachel Ceretto

There are numerous paths by which this waste winds up in the water, says Elizabeth Hogan, WAP’s U.S. oceans and wildlife campaign manager. Gear can malfunction and detach, nets can get stuck on reefs or other objects and never resurface, and, yes, some fishermen simply discard nets and traps out of convenience or as a way to cover their tracks when they’re fishing illegally. The largest contributor to ghost gear, though, is the weather. “I would say [that’s] the primary reason for gear loss,” says Hogan, “and who can argue with bad weather?”

It’s not as if most fishermen want to lose their gear, after all. When a series of storms ravaged the British Isles in the winter of 2013–2014, some crab fishermen lost upwards of $35,000 worth of gear when conditions forced them to abandon their strings of pots.

Whatever the excuse, something needs to be done about it—and this is where Grisafi and Hogan share some optimism. As tagging gear with GPS devices becomes easier and more affordable, Hogan says it will help enormously in the fight against new ghost gear. Similarly, Grisafi points to technology advancements that can help make gear less lethal once it’s lost. These include making fishing nets more biodegradable in general or incorporating biodegradable panels into traps so they no longer continue to catch and kill ad infinitum. Simple tweaks to existing gear, such as adding cull-rings that allow smaller crabs to escape a pot, can also make a big difference.

But there are still miles and miles of drifting killers out there. The NOAA Marine Debris Program finances removal projects so big, they run in the hundreds of thousands of dollars. Projects range from collecting derelict crab pots in the waters off New Jersey to floating traps that catch litter on Maryland’s Anacostia River to removing an 83-foot shipwreck off the Northern Mariana Islands that’s damaging coral habitat.

“We’re just getting started, honestly,” Grisafi says.

That’s why his outlook is positive. Because we’ve only just begun to address this problem, the only way to go is up.

Urge Congress to stand up for the Endangered Species Act


onEarth provides reporting and analysis about environmental science, policy, and culture. All opinions expressed are those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect the policies or positions of NRDC. Learn more or follow us on Facebook and Twitter.

onEarth Story

As the IUCN meets this week in Hawaii, a new report highlights the biggest threats to the planet's most endangered species.

Latest News

After years of fighting to protect their habitat, we did it! Hawaii’s false killer whales now have a chance to come back from the brink.

onEarth Story

On Australia’s Cape York Peninsula, artists weave deadly “ghost nets” into totems.

onEarth Story

Across Africa, more and more people are using antimalarial mosquito nets to catch fish—an ecologically dicey endeavor.

onEarth Story

Who knew the unassuming male pufferfish is one of nature’s greatest artists?

Western Dispatch

Fish farms boost the risks of sea lice infestations, chemicals in the water, and accidental spills that leave native fish floundering.

Personal Action

By simply using less plastic, you can help keep marine life from eating and getting entangled in garbage.

Victory

After years of work by NRDC and its partners, about 5,000 square miles of ocean—with massive canyons, majestic underwater mountains, and more than 1,000 species—have received permanent protection.

onEarth Story

The United States produces two million tons of tire particles each year, and we know very little about what they do to the environment.

Drawing Out the Science

The precious coral canyons and underwater mountains off the east coast of the United States deserve protection.

Policy Primer

Scientists say the species could be functionally extinct in as little as 20 years—but there are some solutions within reach.

Q&A

It’s a complex issue, but NRDC attorney Molly Masterton says that a combination of smart management policies and consumer vigilance is key to the solution.

Join Us

When you sign up you'll become a member of NRDC's Activist Network. We will keep you informed with the latest alerts and progress reports.