At the headwaters of the Amazon River system in eastern Ecuador, the nighttime jungle is not quiet at all. The chatter of nocturnal canopy birds and crickets, mixed with the submarine sonar–like pinging of tree frogs, is startling to the first-time visitor. The 80 or so Waorani villagers who live here find comfort in these sounds. They tell them that their ancestral home is healthy, that it still teems with life, that the relentless march of oil wells and logging into the jungle hasn’t reached here yet.
Waorani hunters leave their village each morning to hunt for food. They’re armed with spears to take down wild boar and blowguns to pick off the woolly monkeys that perch high up in the forest canopy. And though they sometimes must wander farther than they once did, before the arrival of outsiders in this remote region, there is still enough game to sustain them. The jungle provides everything they need, from the fruits of achiote and genipa plants, which they use to make body paint, to the liana vine, which supplies the toxic black juice they put on the points of their darts and spears to paralyze and kill their prey within minutes.
Baihua standing on roots of a Kapok tree David Best
Inside a dirt-floored hut constructed of layered palm fronds, I speak with a muscular, middle-aged man, Penti Baihua, who knew nothing of the outside world until he learned Spanish at an elementary school run by missionaries. He makes the case for the survival of his people, whose way of life today is largely unchanged from that of their ancestors centuries ago. But increasingly, he is seeing oil spills contaminate the jungle and eliminate the game these indigenous people depend on. He is seeing cocoa and coffee plantations replace the rainforest. He knows precisely the stakes for which he is fighting.
“We do not want to disappear,” says Baihua, leader of the Waorani village of Bameno.
Caught In The Middle
To an outsider visiting the rainforest of Ecuador’s Yasuní National Park, one of the most biologically diverse places on earth, it seems almost inconceivable that Baihua and his people have survived as hunter-gatherers there in the 21st century—and even harder to believe they’ll be able to do so for much longer. Momentum is not on their side. This year, in January, drilling began on a new oil well by Petroamazonas, a division of the Ecuadorian state oil company Petroecuador, just 15 miles from the village. It is the first of 97 wells likely to sprout within the national park as a result of the Ecuadorian government’s decision in 2013 to allow petroleum extraction inside the wildlife and anthropological reserve.
Ecuador’s constitution protects the country’s indigenous inhabitants, including the 2,000 or so Waorani, from commercial exploitation—except in the case of oil extraction. If past experience is any guide, the oil development will bring roads into the jungle, followed by illegal loggers, palm oil and cocoa plantations, homesteaders from Ecuador’s impoverished Andes highlands, electrification, and modern housing—the trappings of industrial and economic development.
Julio Etchart/Alamy; Archivio World 3/Alamy
Meanwhile, another force pushes from the south. For the Waorani of Baihua’s community are not alone in the forest.
It takes two days for us to reach Bameno aboard a motorized canoe from Coca, the nearest town with roads and cars, on the Napo River in Ecuador’s eastern Oriente region. Baihua is with us, and as the boat approaches the village along an eerily quiet stretch of dense brush, he points out a bend in the river. My fellow passengers fall into a tense silence. This is a danger zone where members of two Waorani clans, the Taromenane and Tagaeri, have attacked intruders in the past, with deadly results.
The Waorani can be divided into three groups. After the arrival of American missionaries in the 1950s, a large number of the historically nomadic hunter-gatherers converted to Christianity, were educated in Spanish-speaking schools, wore Western clothes, and eventually settled in modern townships as part of the government’s campaign of national integration. Baihua and his “recently contacted” tribe, however, retained their traditional ways and have limited engagement with outsiders. A third group, the 100 to 150 “uncontacted” Taromenane and Tagaeri, continue to live deep within the rainforest, in almost total isolation from the rest of the world.
When Taromenane and Tagaeri happen upon outsiders, including the rest of the Waorani, they tend to throw spears. They appear to believe Baihua’s people are traitors for engaging with the world outside, or possibly for not keeping that outside world away, Baihua tells me. But that’s a matter of speculation. There is no way for Baihua to communicate safely with the uncontacted or to tell them he is as worried about their future in Ecuador’s Yasuní park as he is about his own.
“My father is Awa. He is a great warrior, he defended our Waorani territory with spears,” Baihua wrote about his life in the forest a few years ago. “Now I must defend our territory and the forest with documents and law, speaking Spanish, and traveling far away like the harpy eagle.”
An unassuming leader, he is equally at home helping his wife with her weaving or washing the breakfast dishes as he is leading a hunting party up a mud-sucking riverbank, stepping lightly past anacondas and caimans. He recognizes that Western civilization is closing in on his people. Indeed, he uses a satellite phone to keep in contact with the outside world and his lawyer in New York.
While he wages a campaign for the rights of his people within Ecuador’s multiethnic society, he must also worry about territorial feuds with his rainforest neighbors. In 2003, 26 uncontacted were massacred by Waorani who were allegedly incited and armed by loggers eager to harvest the forest’s ancient cedars. A decade later, a group of uncontacted came across two Waorani elders in the jungle and speared them to death. In retaliation, Waorani murdered 18 members of the uncontacted tribes.
And the conflict continues. Last year, a Waorani couple from Bameno were attacked as they floated upriver. The man was found dead with nine spears in his body; the woman survived and made it back to the village with three spears in her.
Baihua blames the fighting, in large part, on oil. Before the arrival of the drilling crews at its borders, the peoples of Yasuní lived in delicately balanced peace. There were occasional violent encounters, but each group knew where the others hunted and, with game plentiful, they could avoid each other. Now, in a shrinking rainforest, their movements aren’t as predictable, and unexpected encounters lead to death and revenge. If more oil wells are drilled, a full-scale battle for the remaining hunting grounds will erupt, Baihua predicts gravely. “It will be a massacre.”
Boom and Bust
The quest for oil began in the Amazon region in the 1970s, when helicopters carrying seismic crews fanned out over the jungle in search of the crude oil believed to exist in vast deposits beneath the ground. Their work paid off: By 1990, some 214,000 barrels of oil flowed daily from the oil fields around the boomtown of Lago Agrio, then through the 300-mile Trans-Ecuadorian Pipeline to the Pacific Ocean. The steady supply of crude enriched Texaco, Gulf, and other foreign companies, as well as Petroecuador.
But the ecological cost was staggering. New York attorney Judith Kimerling, then acting as NRDC’s Latin American representative, catalogued the environmental toll in Amazon Crude, her 1991 exposé. The drilling operations produced 3.2 million gallons of wastewater a day, which the oil companies stored in unlined pits that leached toxins into the soil and waterways. Also devastating was the estimated 16.8 million gallons of oil spilled from pipelines in the region.
The village elders of Bameno recall helicopters in the skies over Yasuní National Park that dropped lighted dynamite to chase Waorani hunters away from areas the oil companies wanted to explore. Kemperi, one of the Waorani elders, tells me they took up their spears and killed at least 20 oil workers in skirmishes that left several of their own dead as well.
According to Waorani lore, fighting worked. The oil crews left the people of Yasuní alone for at least a decade. Land outside the national park was just as oil-rich, and easier to access. But the Waorani’s peace didn’t last. Those early seismic explorations had determined that more than a billion barrels of oil sat underneath Yasuní. Meanwhile Ecuador—despite charging the foreign oil companies up to 90 percent of revenues in fees and royalties—saw its foreign debt grow to more than $42 billion.
Over the protests of indigenous people and environmentalists, the oil companies set their sights on Yasuní. Then, in 2007, Ecuador’s populist socialist president, Rafael Correa, announced an innovative plan to keep the oil reserves within the national park underground and to protect the Waorani who lived there. He called his scheme the Yasuní ITT Initiative (the initials refer to oil fields within the park) and delivered a challenge to the other nations of the world: In return for a pledge of $3.5 billion from governments and NGOs, Ecuador would leave the rainforest intact.
From left: PNUD representative Rebecca Grynspan, Ecuadorean foreign minister Ricardo Patino, Ecuador vice president Lenin Moreno, and Ecuador's heritage minister Maria Fernanda Espinosa at the signing of the Yasuní ITT Initiative, 2010 Rodrigo Buendia/Getty
Depending on their outlook, commentators called the proposal either visionary or, according to Michael Cepek, an anthropologist at the University of Texas at San Antonio and author of Life in Oil, a cynical gambit that was bound to fail. It could open Yasuní to oil development without guilt on the part of Ecuador’s government. “It was a brilliant policy ploy,” Cepek says. “I don’t think Correa ever intended it to work. He basically said, ‘Put your money where your mouth is; we are a poor country.’”
After an initial outpouring of support and publicity, the ITT Initiative generated just $200 million in pledges before Correa withdrew the offer six years later and said, “The world has failed us.” Petroamazonas announced plans for 651 wells on six blocks of land in and around the national park that essentially targeted the remaining ancestral hunting lands of the Waorani people.
An oil slick–covered stream after a nearby oil facility spilled oil in the Amazon near Lago Agrio, 2003Lou Dematteis/Redux
After that news broke, Baihua could foresee the future. He remembered canoeing on the Tiputini River in 2002 and seeing the aftermath of an oil spill just outside the park boundary. “I have seen for myself the pools of crude that is so black, and sometimes the animals try to drink this water because they think it’s a salt lick,” he told documentary filmmaker Scott Braman. “In February and March, when the animals go to these places for nutrients, they don’t know the danger, and I saw them dead, right there. Capybaras, macaws, agoutis, and guans. These I have all seen dead.”
This new fight would have to be waged with words, not spears, he thought.
In his modern house about 60 miles from Bameno, “Ermenegildo” Criollo, a leader of the Cofán indigenous group, wears casual pants and an orange T-shirt. As he looks out at the village of Dureno, with its tidy streets, basketball court, and 108 modern homes, he recalls his first encounter with the men from far away. He was five years old in 1973 when he heard the whump whump of a helicopter overhead. Months later, the flying machines returned and began dropping “huge machines”―bulldozers that knocked down trees and cleared huge swaths of the rainforest around the future site of Lago Agrio, the oil field developed by Texaco that would eventually produce 1.5 billion barrels of oil.
Criollo recalls workers giving his father cheese, vanilla candy, and a can of diesel oil as compensation for drilling on his family’s land. His father threw away the cheese because it smelled funny. They ate the candy and used the diesel to light lamps. Within months, Criollo saw his first oil spill, one of many that would poison the land. “It painted the river black,” he says, a hint of astonishment in his voice even years later. Both banks of the river the villagers used for drinking and bathing were covered with oil.
Criollo with his wife and child Peter Korn
Nobody told the Cofán the water was contaminated, Criollo says, so people simply pushed aside the oil floating on the surface and continued to drink and bathe in the poisoned water beneath. Villagers developed blisters all over their bodies, and Criollo suffered from severe stomach pains. Even the rainwater became undrinkable, he says. Smoke from gas flares contaminated the air. Criollo has learned that once oil drilling starts, the pollution never ends. “They build a huge spiderweb of oil pipes—they’re not unbreakable forever,” he says. “They don’t say contamination disappears. They say, ‘We’re going to reduce it.’”
In time, the Cofán leaders realized they could make a deal with the oil companies, or they could suffer on without one. Formal agreements were signed three years ago allowing drilling in all but a small parcel of Cofán land that was declared off-limits. In exchange, the oil companies paid to have construction crews move in and build a new house for each family of the community, each one with a long-lasting aluminum roof. There is still no electricity, cell phone access, or internet service, Criollo notes, and the animals the Cofán have hunted for generations have mostly disappeared from the jungle around them—not that the young people seem to care, he says.
“We have received a lot from Texaco,” Criollo says bitterly. “We have received contamination, disease, and death.”
Another advocate for the tribe, Randy Borman, the son of American missionaries who was born in Dureno and lived there for 30 years, says the presence of oil in the ground is a temptation too rich for the Ecuadorian government to ignore. “If there’s a lot of oil there, the oil companies are going to get it,” he says. “Neither private nor public sources are willing to take on the cost of truly and effectively stopping the expansion of the oil and mining industries, much less the continued expansion of far more destructive activities such as oil palm and soya plantations.”
Borman’s advice to the Waorani of Bameno? “Make the best deal possible with that oil company so you can protect what you’ve got.”
Law of the Jungle
Kimerling and Baihua (center) with other WaoraniCourtesy Judith Kimerling
Before Baihua can even attempt to make any kind of deal, he must first win official recognition that the indigenous people living in Yasuní control what happens in their territory, both above and below the ground. That’s the basis of a new proposal formulated by Baihua and attorney Kimerling, who met Baihua in 1989 while researching the oil industry in Ecuador and has represented his people pro bono for years. In April, she and Penti will travel to Ecuador’s capital, Quito, where they have requested a meeting with the country’s president, Lenín Moreno, to make their case.
Ecuadorian law recognizes the rights of indigenous tribes to practice their traditional way of life, but on the ground, those rights haven’t always been protected, says Kimerling, a veteran of previous battles over land use and rights in the Ecuadorian rainforest. A 1990 legal document, for instance, appears to gives the Waorani title to some Yasuní land. Unfortunately, the document includes a clause stipulating that the Waorani cannot obstruct oil or mining on their lands. It assigns title to the land to the government-recognized Waorani Nationality of Ecuador (NAWE), rather than to individual tribal groups. Yet despite several attempts to form a unified tribal entity to represent all of the Waorani, including NAWE, no such entity has ever succeeded in speaking for the whole group for very long.
That’s in part because Waorani society is organized in fiercely independent family groups made up of equals. The notion of organizing, or telling another person what to do, is alien to them, says Baihua. “No one goes to the home of another to obligate,” he once told Kimerling. On top of that, the Waorani today are fractured into three groups with very different priorities.
Armed with a petition signed by a number of Waorani groups, Penti and Kimerling now intend to ask that full land and subsurface rights be given to the Waorani in Yasuní. If the government refuses, and Kimerling suspects it will, the duo hope to secure a guarantee that oil remaining in the lands hunted by the Waorani will stay in the ground. “Ecuador should not be auctioning off the human rights of the Waorani who want to live in the forest,” she says. “Those should not be for sale. Without territory, they will not survive.”
Baihua and Kimerling also hope to revive attempts to find international funding to compensate Ecuador for not extending drilling in Yasuní. Kimerling understands that’s an uphill battle, based on the failure of former president Correa’s ITT Initiative, but hopes the greater global understanding of climate change since the 2016 Paris Agreement will encourage people to support the idea with cash. “A lot of the oil reserves have to stay in the ground if the world is going to meet the Paris agreement,” she says. “Why not start with places that are especially fragile and have community benefits?”
Meanwhile, the “oil frontier,” as Kimerling calls it, has opened on six blocks of land in what has traditionally been Waorani territory, both inside and outside Yasuní National Park. She believes it’s crucial to protect, first, the uncontacted tribes in the park, who stand to lose the most if oil exploration and production destroy their hunting grounds. Without a rallying cry from the uncontacted, she says, oil wells will proliferate deep inside Yasuní. Within 10 or 20 years, it will be too late for any tribe that wishes to maintain its traditional culture.
At the gateway to Yasuní, Baihua takes a break from preparing his canoe for the trip downriver to look at a map of the national park. With a thick and gnarled hunter’s finger he traces a line from west to east across Yasuní, about a third of the way down from the park’s northern edge. This has to be the line, he says. The northern sections of the park have been lost and are no longer suitable for traditional tribes. But if everything south of this line—about 3,000 square miles—is allowed to remain untouched, there will be enough rainforest for his people and the uncontacted tribes to live in peace.
Baihua’s people are survivors. Adaptability is part of their culture. Once, they were jungle dwellers who eschewed the river and its bounty—as the uncontacted tribes still do today. Now, Baihua’s people travel by boat and, when boars are scarce, take catfish and piranha from the river. They have learned to grow manioc and plantains on the outskirts of their village.
The Waorani don’t distinguish between the health of their people and the health of their rainforest, he tells me. Caimans and tapirs, capybaras and toucans, are cause for celebration whenever they are sighted. The Waorani’s trancelike community dance is performed to lyrics that translate to something like “This is us, this is the uncontacted people, we are the land, we are the animals.” And that’s what they wish to remain.
“They keep telling me a small family cannot defend a big territory,” Baihua says, “but I have the right to defend my land.”
onEarth provides reporting and analysis about environmental science, policy, and culture. All opinions expressed are those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect the policies or positions of NRDC. Learn more or follow us on Facebook and Twitter.