Can Anything Be Done to Stop Overfishing?

It’s a complex issue, but NRDC attorney Molly Masterton says that a combination of smart management policies and consumer vigilance is key to the solution.

Tetra Images/Offset

Q: What can be done to eliminate the problem of overfishing? Any ideas?

—Lepa Chapa

A: The stats are bleak: One-third of fish populations worldwide are overexploited or dangerously depleted. And in some cases, overfishing has altered complex marine ecosystems, creating a ripple effect down food chains. Not to mention, its effects are hidden and often difficult to study. When we clear hundreds of acres in the rainforest, we can see the devastation; it’s much harder to witness the depletion of the ocean’s marine life.

NRDC attorney Molly Masterton

Rebecca Greenfield

But there’s hope. Molly Masterton, an NRDC attorney who works to promote healthy marine management, has seen huge strides in policy work geared to restore and maintain sustainable fisheries—the lifeblood of many coastal communities and essential for healthy oceans. “We have come to a point where we needn’t accept overfishing as an unavoidable effect of fishing in our ocean,” she says. “But reining it in requires governments to employ science-based tools and stick-to-itiveness.”

The United States is a global leader in sustainable fishing, with laws such as the Magnuson-Stevens Act, which has helped some of our most iconic fish and shellfish species—like Atlantic sea scallop and haddock—rebound after chronic overfishing through the 1980s and ’90s. Unfortunately, the law is currently under attack in Congress. NRDC is working to defend against proposals to strip protections for fish populations, endangered marine species, and special ocean places like marine monuments. (You can help by contacting your members of Congress to show your support for healthy fisheries and healthy oceans.)

The United States is also a top seafood importer—a unique position that allows us to influence global practices. We consume close to five billion pounds of seafood every year, 90 percent of which is imported, often from countries without rigorous fishery management laws. Federal “traceability standards,” like the U.S. government’s new Seafood Import Monitoring Program, help shed light on unlawful fishing practices and reduce our consumption of illegal products. Before the implementation of this new program, it was estimated that illegally caught fish made up an estimated 30 percent of all our wild-caught seafood imports.

Government policies are key in shaping best practices, but we as consumers also have a role to play. NRDC’s Smart Seafood Buying Guide  offers suggestions for visiting the fish counter, and the Monterey Bay Aquarium’s Seafood Watch app is a comprehensive, science-based guide that will help you weigh your options. Supporting sustainable options with your dollar is critical.

Ultimately, Masterton says, smart management can help shrinking fish populations recover, and luckily the United States and NRDC have been at the forefront of those efforts. But she also cautions that despite our successes with the Magnuson-Stevens Act, there remains much work to be done. Nearly three dozen fisheries are still recovering from overfishing, and systemic problems like bycatch (unintended catch of other wildlife) and damage to marine habitat remain. And NRDC and our partners are not giving up the fight any time soon.

Ultimately, policies to ensure healthy fish populations and marine ecosystems benefit everyone—those of us who enjoy seafood for dinner and those of us whose livelihood depends on it. stories are available for online republication by news media outlets or nonprofits under these conditions: The writer(s) must be credited with a byline; you must note prominently that the story was originally published by and link to the original; the story cannot be edited (beyond simple things such as time and place elements, style, and grammar); you can’t resell the story in any form or grant republishing rights to other outlets; you can’t republish our material wholesale or automatically—you need to select stories individually; you can't republish the photos or graphics on our site without specific permission; you should drop us a note to let us know when you’ve used one of our stories.


The mighty bivalves are both, and this former schoolteacher and bartender seeks to inspire a new generation of aquaculturists while putting North Carolina oysters on the map.

Drawing Out the Science

Important environmental safeguards that puffins depend on for survival, food, and their mighty migration are under siege.

Northeast Dispatch

The state’s thriving lobster industry owes a lot to smart fishery conservation measures implemented over the past three decades. But given the Gulf of Maine’s rapid warming, how far can these interventions go?

Southeast Dispatch

As climate change sends fisheries into flux, managers must keep up with the latest science to sustain them.

Latest News

We got ourselves into this mess. It’s high time we got ourselves out of it.

Western Dispatch

The Aloha State is on track to become the first in the nation to ban shark fishing outright, creating a critical safe harbor for these threatened animals.

Policy Primer

Our current system of managing the waters that cover almost half our planet does little to ensure the long-term survival of marine ecosystems.


A new United Nations treaty is bringing a once-in-a-generation chance to save our open oceans and all the life that depends on them.

onEarth Story

A new report estimates that around 700,000 tons of fishing gear are abandoned in the oceans each year. Now the good news: We can curb this.

Massachusetts Office of Travel & Tourism
onEarth Story

Ocean acidification will hit coastal communities like these the hardest.


How NRDC helped form an unlikely alliance to help protect 38,000 square miles of unique habitat in the Atlantic.

Greg McFall/NOAA
onEarth Story

Why are there so many names for legally protected waterways? And what do they all mean?

onEarth Story

From the mouths of sharks: Humans, please diversify your social circles.

onEarth Story

Consumers want more than fisheries can supply, and certification standards are falling.

onEarth Story

The United States produces two million tons of tire particles each year, and we know very little about what they do to the environment.

onEarth Story

Could Maryland's oyster farms breathe life back into the Chesapeake Bay?

Personal Action

Five ways to ensure the fish you eat is healthy for you and for the environment.

What's At Stake

The earth’s oceans are at a breaking point, and we must help them heal if we want to survive the challenges of climate change.

Join Us

When you sign up you'll become a member of NRDC's Activist Network. We will keep you informed with the latest alerts and progress reports.